chocolate stinger (audrey saunders)

2 oz Pierre Ferrand Ambre Cognac (Courvoisier VS)
1/4 oz Marie Brizard Crème de Menthe (Tempus Fugit)
1/4 oz Marie Brizard Crème de Cacao (Bols White)
1 tsp Kahula
1 dash Bittermens Mole Bitters

Shake with ice and strain into a coupe or an old fashioned glass with ice.

Two Saturdays ago, I decided to make a recipe that I found in Pierre Ferrand's 2016 NYC Cocktail Book called the Chocolate Stinger that was created, or better stated improved upon, by Audrey Saunders at the Pegu Club in Manhattan. The Stinger is a classic first published in 1914 that dates back to the 1890s of shaken instead of stirred Cognac and crème de menthe. It is also a drink that I have a distinct memory of from Russell House Tavern. While we did put it on the menu in 2014, in 2013, I recall two troublesome townie women who sat at my bar one early afternoon and one of them ordered a Stinger. I recall shaking it, serving it on crushed ice, and garnishing with a mint sprig. She was appalled at the presentation and asked for it to be strained. Luckily, when it was later on the menu, my bar manager was smart enough to serve it up. I think that bar guest would be appalled by this variation of a Stinger as well given the excess flavors and lower mint quotient than expected. However, Audrey's recipe was tempting for crème de menthe and cacao work well together as I learned in Death & Co.'s Midnight Mountain and that I utilized in my Year of the Dragon, and minty Fernet works amazingly with crème de cacao. One Instagram friend commented that the Chocolate Stinger reminded them of the After Eight which is crème de menthe with either chocolate or coffee liqueur depending on the recipe with either vodka or Bailey's as the third ingredient; here, all three liqueurs are present, so that observation was rather on point. It turns out that there is a mid-century recipe known as the Chocolate Stinger that is simply the two crème liqueurs with or without vodka shaken together. Given Audrey Saunders' high level of perfecting drinks, it was a good reason to shake up (instead of stir) another straight spirits recipe. In the glass, Audrey's Chocolate Stinger gave forth brandy and mint aromas. Next, mint and roast notes on the sip developed into Cognac, chocolate, and mint flavors on the swallow with coffee and mint on the finish.